Iced Earth - Dystopia

(CD, Century Media, 2011)

I think there is a lot of anxiety for this album from the fans of ICED EARTH who have watched the band changing singer over the years and in the case of Matt Barlow they have done it twice. Since I am a fan of this band from their debut album I was left kind of untouched by the Barlow years and I will boldly state that I consider “Dark Saga” as one of the most simple-constructed album by Jon Schaffer. There I said it; you can throw rocks at me but having this album after the amazing “Burnt Offerings” with the thick dark atmosphere, was a major let down for me.

Nevertheless, a lot of water run under the bridge and ICED EARTH are ready to hit the Metal scene with a new album and a new singer behind the mic who has the duty to stand behind the mic after the second departure of Matt Barlow. To confess to you another truth, I should say that the last two albums with Matt were not that good, at least for my ears...

Fortunately, Jon decided not to continue on the “Something Wicked” storyline apart from two tracks and decided to draw inspiration from literature and movies, a concept that is similar to “Horror Show”. Listening to the album zillion times (more than it is necessary to write a review), I am happy to say that with Stu Block Jon has struck gold. Stu has a voice that impressively stands between Ripper’s aggression and Barlow’s trademark melody and that also means he can deliver the songs of those two eras. The self-titled and album opener will grant my saying kicking in with a Ripper sounding scream and then continues with hearty aggressive singer with an almost Barlow timber from the “Burnt Offerings” days. Music wise the song sounds fresh and fortunately have escaped from the restrictive recipes we all tasted in the band’s previous and definitely weak album. As always the songs are riff based with the trademark granite solid and the galloping-rhythm work we all have learn to love from the very beginning of this US band.

“Anthem” has the killer mid tempo groove and the amazing vocal harmonies that put in bold letter the successful decision by Jon to add Stu in the band. On top of that, the guitar leads are more inspired than the previous album, welcoming the heaviness of ICED EARTH I think most of us have missed. “Dark City” is another track to comment on; it starts with the trademark clean guitar down tuned chords and then gains heaviness as Stu puts his voice into aggression mode while the rhythm part sounds absolutely fantastic backed up with a killer bass sound like the one in “Horror Show” from the DiGiorgio era. “Days Of Rage” has the simple in-your-face attitude similar to “The Hunter”, while “End Of Innocence” follows the classic ICED EARTH ballad recipe with the mix of clean and distorted guitar work and the sing along melodies. In this one, there is “space” for the listener to make a fair judgement on Stu's voice, since here he adds something from his personal style, leaving aside the Ripper / Barlow sounding vocals.

There is no doubt that Schaffer had made a great pick on the singer for ICED EARTH and that is definitely proven in “Dystopia”. I wish and in some extent I feel that the current lineup can stand strong and solid to deliver more albums. Of course, the final and “secure” verdict will be reached in the following tour where Stu will have also to “prove” he has the attitude to keep his singing spot by avoiding the inevitable comparisons. To close this review, I chose the motto printed on the 2008 tour t-shirt when Barlow had returned: "ICED EARTH are back"!

8/10 


Links:

www.IcedEarth.Com
www.FaceBook.Com/OfficialIcedEarth
www.MySpace.Com/IcedEarth


Tracklist:

01. Dystopia
02. Anthem
03. Days Of Rage
04. Soilent Green
05. V
06. Boiling Point
07. Anguish Of Youth
08. Iron Will
09. Dark City
10. End Of Innocence
11. Equilibrium
12. Tragedy & Triumph


Lineup:

Jon Schaffer - Rhythm & Lead Guitar, Vocals
Troy Seele - Lead Guitar
Brent Smedley - Drums
Freddie Vidales - Bass Guitar, Vocals
Stu Block - Lead Vocals